Impact of cold winters on breeding numbers

Numbers were very low prior to the breeding season, following the third consecutive harsh winter, but had recovered strongly by the autumn. It is interesting to compare the peak Oct counts for 2008–2011, which were derived from broadly similar methods by the same observers; suggested explanations for the variations in numbers are given in brackets:

• 2008: 75   (high population after a long run of mild winters)

• 2009: 51   (decrease after the cold snap of Feb 2009)

• 2010: 21   (further decrease after the severe weather of Jan/Feb 2010)

• 2011: 47   (partial recovery after a successful breeding season, in spite of the prolonged cold spell in Nov/Dec 2010)

27/28 Oct – “We caught five unringed Wrens in Millcombe. Till then most had been retraps, so presumed residents. It's possible they [the five unringed birds] suddenly moved into Millcombe from elsewhere on the island, but we got the impression there might have been an influx onto the island.” (Tony Taylor)

Autumn maximum

The highest autumn count was 50 on 21 Sep.

Autumn maximum

The highest autumn count was 52 on 26 Nov.

Autumn maximum

The highest autumn count was 58 on 1 Oct, but only the island south of Halfway Wall was covered.

Autumn maximum

The highest autumn count was 47 on 13 Oct.

Autumn maximum

The highest autumn count was 47 on 10 Nov.

Autumn maximum

The highest autumn count was 37 on 9 Oct. This is unusually low in comparison with recent years; poor summer weather may have reduced breeding success.

Winter count

30 Jan – A total of 37 individuals counted during a walk of the entire island perimeter (Tim Davis & Tim Jones).

Effects of severe cold in early spring

The severe cold spell during Mar (the 'Beast from the East') appears to have depleted the breeding population significantly, particularly along the East Side, where just 12 singing males were found from the north end of the quarries southward, including Millcombe/St John’s, on 3 Jun. This area usually supports a much higher density of Wren territories and BTO BirdTrack data show that Wrens are much more easily detected in Jun than in Jan. Circumstantially, it appeared that birds with West Side territories might have fared better than those on the East Side (which would have been exposed to the full strength of the glacial gales and blizzards); the number of singing Wrens along the West Side was not noticeably lower than normal (Tim Jones).

Autumn maximum

The highest autumn count was 30 on 24 Oct.

Autumn maximum

The highest autumn count was 25 on 23 Oct.

Ringing

Ringing recovery

A Wren ringed as a first-year bird on Lundy on 23 Sep 2014 (ring no. HBP948) was found dead at Bothenhampton, Bridport, Dorset on 21 Oct 2014 (28 days, 144 km, ESE 111º). This is the first known movement of a Wren either to or from the island (from more than 1,200 ringed). That it should relate to a distance as great as 144 km is quite remarkable!

New record

25 Oct – One.

New record

14, 15 & 27 Sep – One.

New records

20 to 28 Oct – Singles present on 17 dates in this period, plus two on 16th.

22 Nov – One.

28 Dec – One.

New record

31 Jan – One. The first for the island during the period Jan–Mar and most likely the same individual seen in Nov & Dec 2010; the first known instance of overwintering on Lundy.

New record

29 May – A female with a brood patch was trapped and ringed on 29 May. There were no records before or after this date and it seems likely that this bird was a wandering individual that had perhaps failed to breed successfully on the mainland.

New record

30 Aug – A juvenile was trapped and ringed in Millcombe. Note: This record was accidentally omitted from the 2013 LFS Annual Report.

New record

20 Sep to 2 Oct – One in Millcombe on four dates 20–27 Sep was trapped and ringed on 27th (Chris Dee, Andy Jayne et al.) but found dead on the Beach Road on 2 Oct.

New records

13 Sep – One on the Terrace on 13 Sep (Dave Chown) and in Millcombe.
1 & 2 Oct – one in Millcombe (trapped and ringed on 1st – John Horton).

New records

17 & 19 Mar – A single bird was present; it was seen in a conifer behind Millcombe House on the latter date.

18 to 30 Sep – A single bird was seen on four dates during this period (Andy Jayne et al.).

10 Oct – Sightings at different times in Millcombe (Andrew Jewels) and Quarter Wall Copse (Kevin Waterfall), could possibly have involved two different individuals.

New record

6 Apr – One was found in Millcombe during the mid afternoon (Zoë Barton & Dean Jones). It was watched until 18:00 hrs "as it busily picked its way through every bit of lichen and bryophyte throughout the valley looking for a meal." It could not be found the next day.

New records

26 Mar – In one of the more unlikely observations of the year, one was feeding amongst rocks at Jenny’s Cove (Andy Jayne).

24 & 25 Sep – One was in Millcombe Wood on 24 & 25 Sep.

8 to 25 Oct – What is considered to have been a different bird was in Millcombe on 8th, remaining until 25th (ringed on 22nd).

New record

7 to 11 Sep – One was in Millcombe (Rebecca Taylor et al.).

New record

21 Mar – One was foraging on sycamores in Millcombe, at one point in the same tree as a Long-tailed Tit (Dean Jones).

New records

Recorded on nine dates, one in spring and eight in autumn.

26 Apr – One in Millcombe Stuart Cossey).

17 Sep to 15 Oct – One was ringed on 17 Sep and seen again the next day (Chris Dee, Angus Croudace et al.). Singles were in Millcombe on 2 Oct (Matt Stritch) and on five dates from 10 to 15 Oct (Tom Wright, Chris Dee et al.). The latter bird was trapped and ringed on 12^th.

New record

11 Sep – One in Millcombe (Adam Day).

New records

12 Sep – A juvenile was seen around the village (S. Barnes, A. Plant, A.M.Taylor et al.). Record accepted by DBRC.

21 & 22 Oct – A juvenile was seen in Millcombe, associating with Fieldfares as well as with Starlings (J. Allen, R.A. Duncan, A.M. Taylor et al.). Record accepted by DBRC.

These constitute the 14th and 15th Lundy records, which have involved a total of at least 19 individuals. The most recent occurrence prior to 2007 was a juvenile on 5 & 6 Sep 2004.

New records

24 Sep to 15 Oct – A juvenile found in Millcombe on 24 Sep (A. Turner) was trapped and ringed on 25th and retrapped on 30th (D. Baggott, C. Dee, J. Griffin, A. Turner et al.) and last seen in the field on 4 Oct. The presence of a second, unringed bird was confirmed on 1 Oct. This bird tended to spend its time around the Village, where it frequently roosted with House Sparrows and Starlings in the farmyard buildings, remaining to at least 13 Oct (T. Davis, J. Diamond, T. Jones et al.). Both birds were seen together on 3 & 4 Oct. The decomposed corpse of the first, ringed bird, was found near Brambles on 15 Oct. Records accepted by DBRC; these constitute the 16th and 17th Lundy records, the last being two juveniles in Sep 2007.

New records

21 Jun – An adult was with Starlings in the vicinity of Quarter Wall and the Brick Field and later on a wall near the Lodge (John & Silvia Buchanan, Duncan Matheson et al).

17 to 24 Aug – A juvenile was around the farmyard (Grant Cozens, Richard Taylor, Tony Taylor et al.). Photo © Richard Taylor.

Records accepted by DBRC; the 18th and 19th for Lundy.

New record

14 Jun – A first-summer bird that had moulted from juvenile plumage into partial breeding plumage was photographed in Pigs’ Paradise gardens and sitting on top of the Church (Rebecca Bates, Robert Foster, Tim Davis, Tim Jones). Record accepted by DBRC; the 20th for Lundy.

New records

1 Jun– A breeding-plumaged adult was in St Helen’s Field, immediately outside Barton Cottages, on 1 Jun (Dean Jones, Tony Taylor).

26 Aug – A juvenile was in Millcombe and in Tillage & St Helen’s Fields on 26 Aug (Richard & Rebecca Taylor, Tony Taylor). Records accepted by DBRC; the 21st and 22nd for Lundy

New records

3 Jun – Two adults (presumed m & f, as one a distinctly brighter, sharper bird) were seen at Quarter Wall (main track gate) at 06.15 hrs. At 08.30 they were flying down St John's Valley and then perched on the Church before dropping down into the Tent Field, where they were still present 09.40–10.00, though by 10.00 the two birds appeared to have split up, with only the (presumed) female seen later in the day, e.g. Tilllage Field pig sty at 18.30 (Tim Davis & Tim Jones).

9 to 29 Jun – One seen initially with Common Starlings near Old Light during the morning of 9th by one of the Manx Shearwater survey team, then by Frances Stuart and Rebecca & Richard Taylor in the afternoon, when it was wheeling around Millcombe. Potentially one of the birds seen on 3rd, but perhaps more likely a new arrival given the exceptional 'invasion' of this species into western Europe during June 2018, this individual remained on the island until 29 Jun.

6 Sep – A juvenile was around the chicken run outside Quarters (Rebecca & Rich Taylor, Tony Taylor et al.)

Records accepted by DBRC.

New record

6 to 21 Oct – A juvenile at the Tillage/Brick Field pigsty, seen briefly on 6th (Ryan Miller), was relocated in the farmyard on 9th, where it remained – focused on the food dispenser in the chicken run! – with forays to the Lambing Shed and Lighthouse Field, often showing at very close range to multiple observers until its last appearance on 21st (Dean Jones). The 26th record for the island. Record accepted by DBRC.

New record

21 Jun – One in Millcombe (Dean Jones). "A superb adult Rose-coloured Starling in Millcombe within a small flock of juvenile Common Starlings first thing. The bird was rather flighty at first, providing only brief views on the wing, before it finally settled upon the Sycamores near Bramble Villas for a brief rest before disappearing towards the Village." Record accepted by DBRC; the 27th for Lundy.

New record

14 Jun – An adult was around the Campsite, Bull’s Paradise and the Lambing Shed area during the morning, a day when the island was shrouded in fog. It flew off into the murk at about 11:00 hrs and was not seen again (Matt Stritch et al.).

Record accepted by DBRC.

New record – subject to acceptance by DBRC

3 to 17 Sep – A juvenile first seen in Millcombe, below Government House, on 3^rd was still present around the Village on 17^th at least (Joe Parker et al.).

Photo: Starling along the High Street, 28 Apr 2014 © Richard Campey

Migration extensing into mid-Dec

10 & 11 Dec – Migration continued well into Dec, with flocks seen leaving the island high to the north-west, into a headwind, on 10 Dec and to the south-east, following a change in wind direction, on 11th.

Notable autumn-passage count

7 Nov – The arrival of 2,000 was (at that time) the highest count since The Birds of Lundy was published.

Breeding summary

Adults were seen taking food to nest sites in the last week of May, with at least 11 active nests located: in the laundry, the ranger’s workshed, Barton Cottages (two nests), dog shed, communications shed, south and west walls of the workshop (two pairs), Old Light (two pairs) and the Church (Tim Davis & Tim Jones). Young from two other nests built inside the workshop may already have fledged by this date. The first fledgling was seen begging for food on the roof of The Barn on 30 May (Isabel Winney). Three weeks later, most young had not only fledged but reached independence (e.g. a flock of 14 juveniles on the Airfield on 19 Jun), though adults were continuing to carry food to a nest in the Campsite wall of the workshop on the same date.

Notable autumn-passage counts

17 Oct to 14 Nov – A large influx was noted on 17 Oct, with 750 reported from North Light. Numbers then remained high well into Nov, with maxima of 1,000 on 25 Oct, 1,200 on 27th, 500 on 30th and 500 again on 14 Nov.

Notable autumn-passage count

16 & 17 Nov – Autumn migration peaked at 3,500 on 16th and 3,100 on 17th. These remain the highest Starling counts for the island since publication of The Birds of Lundy, though are well short of the all-time maximum of 10,000+ recorded in 1953, 1959 and 1973.

Breeding summary

The spring pre-breeding maximum was 90 on 21 & 26 Mar. Successful breeding confirmed: adults were seen commuting back and forth to nest sites, carrying food, on 29 Apr; 37 occupied nests were counted on 3 May, including those in the Church, Village and Old Light complex (Tim Jones), and the first fledgling was seen by the Ranger’s Shed on 9 May (Dean Jones). The post-breeding summer peak was 130 on 8 Jul.

Breeding summary

A census of nests in the Village and at the Old Light complex, carried out between 31 May and 3 Jun (Tim Jones), produced a minimum of 39 active nests, all of which had young being fed. A couple of nests at least had already fledged, so it is safe to say that there were over 40 nests; the highest total ever recorded, providing more circumstantial evidence of the benefits of rat eradication for hole-nesting landbirds (in addition to seabirds as the prime target beneficiaries).

Breeding summary – a new record number of nests

A total of 56 active nests were located on 10 Jun in the Village, Church and Old Light (Dean Jones). The first fledglings of the year were not seen until 22 Jun (some three weeks later than in 2018).

Notable autumn-passage count

17 Nov – An estimated 1,000 birds, involving a “single flock of 800-900 Starlings in off the South End first thing; the noise upon arrival was incredible. The entire flock then settled in Barton Field to feed – scaring the life out of the ponies! Birds were also arriving from the north in small but steady flocks – estimate at least 1,000+ birds overall – an incredible sight!” (Dean Jones & Zoë Barton).

Ringing

Ringing recovery: A Starling ringed as an adult male on Lundy on 24 Oct 2012 (ring no. LB46253) was found freshly dead, having been killed by a cat, at Bierbergen, Hohenhameln, (about 25 km SE of Hanover), Niedersachsen, Germany on 23 Mar 2013 (150 days; 1,025 km; E 84°).

New record

7 to 22 Oct – A typically wary and elusive individual was seen in Millcombe during the early morning, but could not be relocated after about 08.30 hrs (Dean Jones). However, it was trapped and ringed on the morning of 9th, when it was aged as a first-year bird, though wing-length was in the overlap zone between male and female. Thereafter, it was seen intermittently in Millcombe, mainly frequenting the wooded area on the south side of the valley, though often seeming to 'disappear' for long periods and usually being seen briefly – either in flight or perched in dense cover – though a few lucky observers had more prolonged views of it perched. It was retrapped on 17th, when it was found to be in good health, having put on significant body fat, and seen feeding in the relative open near Government House on 22nd. There has been one previous Lundy record – a first-year male, also in Millcombe, that was first seen on 15 Oct 1952 and remained on the island until 8 Nov. Record accepted by BBRC.

Correction The 27 Oct record should be deleted. The final two paragraphs of the Grey-cheeked Thrush species account (p.185) confirm that while the corpse was initially identified as that of Swainson's Thrush, it was later found to be almost certainly a Grey-cheeked Thrush. This means that there are only two accepted records of Swainson's Thrush for Lundy.

Earliest and latest since 2006 (last year covered in full by The Birds of Lundy): Earliest in spring 17 Mar 2009 (one), Latest in spring 11 May 2007 (one); Earliest in autumn 15 Sep 2017 (two), Latest in autumn 14 Nov 2017 (one).

Notable autumn-passage count

14 Oct – A count of 15 was the highest since Oct 2005 (when there were 20 on 18th) and remains the highest since publication of The Birds of Lundy.

Notable spring-passage count

8 Apr – A count of seven remains the highest since publication of The Birds of Lundy.

New record set for latest bird in autumn

14 Nov – A single bird on this date beat the previous 'latest ever' (11 Nov 1993) by three days.

New record set for highest-ever count for the island

15 Oct – A remarkable count of 25 scattered along the East Side between Millcombe and the north end of the Quarries (including two flying in off the sea) was the highest ever for Lundy, the previous record being 20 on 2 & 3 Oct 1951.

Notable autumn-passage count

20 Oct – A total of 20 was logged, coinciding with a major influx of other thrushes. Of these, 18 were recorded over-flying Millcombe and/or dropping into the valley to feed and rest during the first three hours of daylight.

Autumn passage influx

24 Oct to 26 Nov – there was a major influx at the end of Oct, following a period of easterly winds. On 24 Oct, 13 were flushed from the former garden at Stoneycroft, while seven flew out of the nettle bed outside the former lantern room at the base of the Old Light on 25th. Similar numbers could be encountered in any area of sheltered cover, particularly away from the exposed East Side. Maxima rose from 30 on 22nd to 110 on 23rd, peaked at 150 on 25th, but remained at 100 on 28th, before dropping significantly to 20 on 29th, following a change to more favourable weather conditions. However, a further influx resulted in counts of 100 on 6 & 8 Nov, with 55 still present on 16th.

Autumn passage influx

16 to 30 Oct – There was no evidence of any real movement in Sep and though counts occasionally reached double digits in the first half of Oct, it was not until 16
Oct that a noticeable arrival of 45 birds occurred. A further influx at the end of the month brought 40 on 28th, 65 on 29th and an exceptional 200 on 30th.

Ringing

Ringing recovery: A Blackbird ringed as a first-year female on Lundy on 21 Oct 2007 (ring no. CW21961) was found freshly dead (having hit a window) at Echt-Susteren, Limburg, The Netherlands (51°05’N, 5°53’E) on 10 Jun 2008 (233 days; 736 km; E 91°).

Ringing recovery (on-island): A Blackbird ringed as a juvenile male on Lundy on 12 Sep 2010 (ring no. LB46135) was found deadon Lundy on 27 Sep 2013 – some 1,111 days later.

Ringing control: A Blackbird ringed as a first-year female on 15 Oct 2012 (Stavanger ring no. 7576377) at Søre Merkeskog, on the North Sea island of Utsira, Rogaland, Norway was controlled on Lundy, on 23 Oct 2013 (374 days; 1,086 km; SSW 214°). Given that Utsira, like Lundy, is a small offshore island, it is likely that this individual was ringed during its autumn migration from a breeding area further to the north-east.

Ringing recovery: A Blackbird ringed as an adult female on Lundy on 16 Nov 2013 (ring no. LB46284) was found dead (road casualty) at Getterön, Varberg, Halland, Sweden on 21 Oct 2014 (348 days; 1,283 km; ENE 59°).

Ringing recovery: The ring only of a Blackbird ringed as an adult female on Lundy on 25 Oct 2007 (ring no. LA36779) was found using a metal detector in a Raven nest being used by a Peregrine, at at Cwar yr Hendre, Powys on 18 Dec 2015 (2,976 days; 119 km; NE 53°). It is likely that the bird had been long dead when the ring was found.

Earliest and latest since 2006 (last year covered in full by The Birds of Lundy): Earliest 6 Oct 2007 (one); Latest 22 May 2016 (three).

Notable autumn-passage count

19 Oct – A strong southward diurnal passage involved at least 1,180 birds. Prior to the events of Ocotber 2022 (see below) this was the second-highest count ever recorded on the island (following 1,500 on 4 November 1981).

Record autumn-passage count

Cold-weather influx

15 Dec – A flock of 64 arrived following a period of freezing conditions on the mainland.

Ringing

Ringing recovery: A Fieldfare ringed as a first-year male on Lundy on 21 Oct 2007 (ring no. CW21959) was found freshly dead at Littlehampton, Sussex on 12 Nov 2007 (22 days; 295 km; E 98º).

Earliest and latest since 2006 (last year covered in full by The Birds of Lundy): Earliest 27 Sep 2012 (one); Latest 17 May 2013 (one).

Significant autumn-passage influx

15 to 26 Oct – A significant influx during the second half of Oct included 100 on 15th, 120 on 21st, 350 on 23rd and two huge counts (for Lundy) of 1,500 on 24th and 2,000 on 25th, falling to 600 on 26th, 300 on 27th and 150 on 28th. The all-time maximum for the island was 2,500 on 24 Oct 1974. The count of 2,000 on 25 Oct was matched on 29 Oct 2014 but remains the highest since publication of The Birds of Lundy.

Notable autumn-passage count

16 Nov – A count of 1,200 was one of the larger totals recorded in recent years.

Significant autumn-passage influx

29 Oct – A count of 2,000 matched that of 25 Oct 2012 as the highest since publication of The Birds of Lundy.

Notable autumn-passage count

26 Oct – A count of 1,200 was one of the larger totals recorded in recent years.

High numbers early in the year and impact of the 'Beast from the East'

At the start of the year, unusually high numbers remained on the island from the influxes of the previous autumn and early winter, with maxima of 37 on 5 Jan, 22 on 12 Feb and 25 on 22 Feb. A significant new influx coincided with the severe cold weather of early Mar, with 31 on 3rd, 257 on 4th (scattered across the whole island, though most in Brick, Tillage and St Helen’s  Fields), 52 on 5th, 124 on 6th and 48 on 7th. Numbers were subsequently much lower, with observations on just six dates, including a peak of 11 on 28 Mar, until the last of the spring, a single bird on 4 Apr.

Ringing

Ringing control: A Redwing ringed as an adult on Lundy on 27 Oct 2006 (ring no. RT24343) was controlled on 18 Oct 2007 at Hamme Sint-Anna, Oost-Vlaanderen, Belgium (51°06’N, 4°09’E). (356 days; 615 km; E 91°).

Ringing recovery: A Redwing ringed as an adult on Lundy on 29 Oct 2008 (ring no. RF31057) was found dead on 10 Jan 2010 at Furbo, Co. Galway, Ireland (438 days; 385 km; NW 307°). Furbo is right on the Atlantic coast and it is likely that many wintering Redwings headed to westernmost Ireland to seek refuge from the freezing temperatures and heavy snow that affected the UK and much of continental Europe between mid-Dec 2009 and mid-Jan 2010. A satellite image taken on 7 Jan 2010 shows virtually the whole of the UK and eastern Ireland blanketed by snow, with only western Ireland snow free.

Ringing control: A Redwing ringed as a first-year bird on Lundy on 29 Oct 2009 (ring no. RF40556) was controlled on 12 Jun 2012 at Pihlajaniemi, Kerimäki, Mikkeli, Southern Savonia, Finland (958 days; 2,398 km; ENE 60°). The control site is on a lake peninsula in the far SE of Finland, close to the Russian border. Perhaps this bird was already back in its breeding area, but given that spring was cold and late in northern Europe in 2012, it is also possible that it was still migrating, perhaps heading even further east into Russia.

Breeding season summary

In spite of the severe cold of Feb 2009, there were two territorial pairs (both seen carrying food in May) and a fledgling was seen in Millcombe on 14 May, with a well-grown juvenile seen there on 7 Aug.

Breeding season summary

Singing birds were holding territory in Millcombe/St Helen’s Copse and Quarter Wall Copse in early Jun, but there was no evidence of breeding.

Breeding season summary

For the second year running no evidence of successful breeding was reported and for the first time since the mid-1980s there were no records of singing (i.e. territory holding) males. This is most likely a consequence of three consecutive hard winters. Equally remarkably, Song Thrush was not recorded at all in Sep, with a thin autumn passage not really getting underway until mid-Oct.

Breeding season summary

No singing males or other evidence of breeding for the third consecutive year.

Autumn influx

22 to 27 Oct – A major influx towards the end of Oct brought 60 on 22nd, rising to 80 on 23rd & 24th and an exceptional 150 on 25th, before falling to a still notable 60 on 26th and 40 on 27th. The count of 150 on 25th remains the highest since publication of The Birds of Lundy but falls a considerable way short of the all-time record of 500 on 25 Oct 1973!

Notable winter count

25 Dec – A count of 25 remains the highest winter (Dec to Feb) count since publication of The Birds of Lundy.

No evidence of breeding attempts

There were no territory holding birds in spring and no other evidence that breeding was attempted.

Autumn influx

26 to 31 Oct – A significant influx  brought 100+ on 26th and over 30 on 27th and 31st. Alongside Redwings and Blackbirds, Song Thrushes remained a feature of island birding until the end of the year.

Notable winter count

28 Dec – A count of 16 was one of the higher winter (Dec to Jan) counts of recent years.

Notable winter counts

5 & 27 Jan – Counts of 21 on 5th and 24 on 27th were among the higher winter (Dec to Feb) counts of recent years.

Autumn influx

15 Oct – A notable influx of 60 birds – by far the highest count of the autumn.

Earliest and latest dates since 2006 (last year covered in full by The Birds of Lundy): Earliest in spring 18 Feb 2014 (one), Latest in spring 4 Jun 2018 (one); Earliest in autumn 6 Oct 2007 (one); Latest in autumn 23 Nov 2015 (one) – but see also midwinter records below.

Midwinter record

29 Jan – A group of three.

High count in autumn

18 & 19 Oct  – A count of eight remains the highest since publication of The Birds of Lundy.

Midwinter record

26 & 27 Dec – A group of three on 26th and a single bird on 27th had probably moved in response to severe winter weather on the mainland.

Winter record

26 & 28 Feb – One was near the Heinkel wreck on 26th (Louise Cookson & Trevor Dobie/LFS Working Party) and below Benjamin's Chair on 28th (Zoë Barton & Dean Jones).

Late spring/early summer record

4 Jun – One was in the vicinity of the Logan Stone, at the eastern end of Halfway Wall on this unusual date (Tim Davis & Tim Jones).

New record

26 Oct – A first-winter bird watched and photographed in Millcombe and St John's Valley (Paul Holt) at 13.50 hrs stayed for only 15 minutes or so and could not be relocated. Record accepted by BBRC; the 4th  for Lundy following others in 1952, 1962 and 1982, all of which occurred between 27 Oct and 18 Nov.

American Robin, Millcombe, 26 Oct 2018
© Paul Holt

Earliest and latest since 2006 (last year covered in full by The Birds of Lundy): Earliest in spring 19 Apr 2012 (one); Latest in autumn 17 Oct 2008 & 2010 (one).

Notable spring-passage count

2 May – A count of 45 is the second-highest spring total since The Birds of Lundy was published, being exceeded only in May 2019 (see below).

Notable autumn-passage count

10 Sep – A count of 50 remains the highest autumn total since The Birds of Lundy was published.

Notable spring-passage count

9 May – A spectacular fall of 80, on a sunny but windy morning after a stormy day on 8th, is the highest spring count since The Birds of Lundy was published.

New record set for autumn-passage maximum

14 Oct – A count of 80 was the highest ever made on Lundy (the previous all-time maximum being 75 on 29 Oct 2004).

Notable autumn-passage count

23 Oct – A count of 65; one of the higher totals for the island (see above).

Breeding season

16–20 Apr – Up to six potential breeding territories located, with singing males in Millcombe (three), St Helen’s Combe (one) and Quarter Wall Copse (two).

Notable winter count

30 Dec – A count of 12 was the first double-digit count in winter (Dec to Feb) since publication of The Birds of Lundy and remains the third highest ever.

Notable winter count

27 Jan – A count of 15 was the highest winter (Dec to Feb) count since publication of The Birds of Lundy, following on from high numbers at the end of 2017 and remains the second highest ever recorded (after 20 on 27 Dec 2000).

New record

28 Sep – One was found skulking in rushes around Pondsbury (E. Davis, B. Heasman, I. Lakin et al.) and what was presumably the same bird was seen at Quarter Wall on 1 Oct (E. Davis). Record accepted by DBRC – the 9th occurrence on Lundy and the first in autumn since 1964. More recent sightings have all been in May, including the last in 2004.

New record

9 May – A female seen and photographed amongst rushes near the water tanks in the south-east corner of Ackland’s Moor (R. Campey). Record accepted by DBRC; only the 10th for Lundy.

New record

13 May – A female was flushed along the Lower East Side Path a little way north of Mousehole & Trap. It was extremely skulking and last seen diving for cover low down on a buttress on the southern edge of Gannets' Combe (Tim Davis & Tim Jones).

Record accepted by DBRC, the 11th Lundy record and the sixth in a narrow window between 9 & 27 May.

New record

1 May – One mist-netted and ringed in Millcombe (Colin McShane) was the first occurrence since one was seen in St John's Valley in May 2005.

NB This record was included in the 2010 ringing totals in the 2010 LFS Annual Report but inadvertently omitted from the full systematic list in the Bird Report that year.

New record

25 Aug – A first-year bird was mist-netted and ringed in Millcombe (Tony Taylor). The tenth Nightingale to be ringed on Lundy. Record accepted by Devon Bird Recorder.

New record

20 Apr – One in Millcombe (Dean Jones). Record accepted by DBRC.

New record

28 Apr – One trapped and ringed in Millcombe (Rob Duncan, Dean Jones, David Kightley).

25 Aug – A remarkably confiding individual was at the top of Smelly Gully – in the same area as a Wryneck – and feeding on grass around Millcombe Pond (Dean Jones et al.).

Records accepted by DBRC; only the fifth & sixth Nightingales for Lundy of the 21st century.

New record – subject to acceptance by DBRC

28 Aug – One was seen in bracken north of the quarries (Luke Marriner).

New record

18 Oct – A first-winter bird was trapped at 09:40 in a mist-net set in the gully below Brambles. It was promptly ringed, photographed and released outside Brambles, whereupon it flew strongly over the treetops and down into Lower Millcombe. An hour later it was retrapped in a different mist-net in Millcombe, but released immediately. At 17:30 it was seen briefly once more, perched and flying into a tamarisk bush in Millcombe (A.M. Taylor, F. Watts et al.). This is the second record for Lundy following one in Oct 2005. Record accepted by BBRC. 

Earliest and latest since 2006 (last year covered in full by The Birds of Lundy): Earliest in spring 2 Apr 2019 (one, male), Latest in spring 2 Jun 2018 (one); Earliest in autumn 8 Aug 2014 (one), Latest in autumn 23 Oct 2011 (one).

Notable autumn-passage count

10 Sep – A count of 15 remains the joint second-highest autumn total since The Birds of Lundy was published (see 2018 records below).

Notable spring-passage count

2 May – A count of 10 remains the highest spring total since The Birds of Lundy was published.

No spring-passage records

For the first time in many years there were no spring records, perhaps a reflection of the cool, unsettled conditions, but also gaps in observer coverage.

Notable autumn-passage count

25 Aug – A count of 11 was one of the higher autumn totals of recent years.

Notable autumn-passage counts

31 Aug & 2 Sep – A count of 20 on 31 Aug was the highest autumn total since The Birds of Lundy was published. A further notable count of 15 was made on 2 Sep, equalling the total for 10 Sep 2009.

Ringing

Ringing control: A Pied Flycatcher ringed as a pullus (nestling) at Llananno, Powys, on 11 Jun 2006 (ring no. T733340) was controlled as an adult male on Lundy on 08 May 2008 (697 days; 162 km; SW 215°) – a further ringing movement suggesting that many of the Pied Flycatchers seen on Lundy in spring are from the Welsh breeding population.

Unproven report

12 May – An adult male was reported along the Lower East Side Path between the [then] northernmost clump of rhododendrons and the Terrace Trap. A description was submitted to BBRC, but the Committee assessed the record as 'not proven'. A record for Quarter Wall Copse in October 1986 was also not accepted by BBRC, so there have yet to be any authenticated occurrences of this species on Lundy.

Earliest and latest since 2006 (last year covered in full by The Birds of Lundy): Earliest in autumn 21 Sep 2009 (one), Latest in autumn 5 Nov 2007 (one); only one spring record, 31 May 2016.

New records

8 & 10 Oct – A first-winter bird was seen in Millcombe on both dates; apparent plumage differences and the lack of any sighting on 9th (in spite of thorough searching) suggested that two individuals could have been involved (C. Baillie, T. Davis, T. Jones et al.). Record accepted by DBRC.

5 Nov – An adult male in Millcombe (Peter Davies). Record accepted by DBRC.

New records

21 to 24 Sep – One first seen below Brambles on 21st was seen daily in Millcombe. It was caught, ringed and aged as a first-winter on 23rd (Derek Baggott, Chris Dee, Andy Turner). Record accepted by DBRC.

New record

15 Oct – A first-winter bird was trapped, ringed and photographed in Millcombe on 15 Oct (Richard Taylor, Tony Taylor et al.) Record accepted by DBRC. Photo © Richard Taylor.

New records

8 to 10 Oct – One, thought to be a first-winter bird, was in St Helen’s Copse on 8th (Malcolm Shakespeare) with one in Millcombe the following day (John Horton et al.). On 10th two were seen together in Millcombe, feeding above the Casbah in shelter from north-east winds (John Haddaway & John Horton). Records accepted by DBRC.

New record

28 & 29 Oct – One in Millcombe, in the vicinity of the Casbah, (James Diamond et al.).

New record

15 Oct – A first-winter bird was watched at close range in Millcombe in an area between the Casbah, Government House and Millcombe House (Tim Jones et al.). Record accepted by DBRC.

New records

31 May – A female or first-year male in St Helen's Copse (Paul Holt). This is the first spring record since Jun 2003.

1 Oct – One was in Millcombe in the vicinity of the walled gardens and lower slopes of the Ugly (Paul Sterry, Tim Jones).

Records accepted by DBRC.

Red-breasted Flycatcher, St Helen's Copse,
31 May 2016 © Paul Holt

New records

15 Oct – One in the Terrace Trap willows and later at Quarry Pond (Richard Campey).

28 Oct – One in Millcombe (Andy Jayne).

Records accepted by DBRC.

New records

6 Oct – A first-winter bird in Quarter Wall Copse (Paul & Jackie Holt, Dean Jones).

18 Oct – A first-winter bird in Quarter Wall Copse (Dean Jones). Plumage differences apparent in photographs identified this as a different individual to the one seen on 6th.

Records accepted by DBRC.

New records

20 Oct – Following a wild night of torrential thundery showers with lightning and a westerly gale, it was something of a surprise when a first-winter Red-breasted Flycatcher turned up at about 09:30 hrs, feeding along the sheltered northern edge of Millcombe Wood between the Casbah and Brambles. At times it perched prominently in the open, but more often moved rather elusively among the branches and bunches of Turkey oak and sycamore leaves. It spent much of the day in Millcombe but turned up in St Helen's Copse later in the afternoon (Tim Jones et al.).

2 Nov – One was seen in the walled gardens of Millcombe (Eleanor Grover). Writing for the Lundy Birds blog at the time, Eleanor related: “Checking through a group of feeding Chiffchaffs revealed a surprising find: not a warbler at all but a Red-breasted Flycatcher. Flitting about in the trees, it paused only to seemingly smirk at the camera being pointed at it, before dropping down into thicker branches and being lost from view. A delightful little bird, it appeared and then disappeared all in the space of the time it took to check the mist-nets and, unfortunately, was not resighted again.”

Records accepted by DBRC.

New record

27 Oct – A first-winter bird was found at the top of Millcombe (Chris Baillie, Stuart Cossey, Angus Croudace, Tom Wright).

Record accepted by DBRC.

New record – subject to acceptance by DBRC

20 Oct – One seen briefly in alders on the north side of Quarter Wall Copse during the late afternoon (James Diamond) was heard calling in the same area shortly afterwards (Joe Parker) but could not be relocated visually.

Earliest and latest since 2006 (last year covered in full by The Birds of Lundy): Earliest in autumn 3 Oct 2015 (one), Latest in spring 22 Jun 2010 (one).

Winter record

17 Feb – One, adding to the relatively few winter (Dec to Feb) records for Lundy.

Winter record

24 to 28 Dec – One; see comment for Dec 2007.

Winter record

9 Dec – One at the top of Puffin Slope; see comment for Dec 2007.

Notable autumn-passage count

31 Oct – 20 were in the area close to North Light. This remains the highest total since The Birds of Lundy was published.

Late-spring/Early-summer record

17 to 22 Jun – A female was seen at Jenny’s Cove on 17, 21 & 22 Jun. While late spring migrants or wandering failed/non-breeding individuals have occasionally been seen in Jun in previous years, this appears to be the latest on record.

Notable spring-passage counts

5 & 6 Apr – Four on both dates remain the highest spring counts since The Birds of Lundy was published.

Notable autumn-passage counts

25 & 26 Oct – During strong easterly winds, seven were feeding in the shelter and relative warmth of the west sidelands between Shutter Point and Dead Cow Point on 25th. The next day, the all-island count reached 12.

Winter record

30 Jan – One; the first winter record since Dec 2009.

Late-spring/Early-summer record

28 May – One at Long Roost (Grant Sherman).

Winter records

27 & 28 Dec – A female on 27th and a male on 28th were the only winter records.

Late-spring/Early-summer record

7 Jun – A female was in Gannets’ Combe; an unusually late date (Tim Jones).

Winter record

18 Dec – One near the Church (Philip & Helen Lymbery).

Winter records

25 Jan to 4 Feb – Single birds were noted on each date, the bird on 27th at Jenny’s Cove.

12 Dec – One.

Late-spring/Early-summer record

18 Jun – One.

Winter records

31 Jan – Two female-type birds below Benjamin's Chair (Tim Jones).

15 Feb – One below Benjamin's Chair (Dean Jones).

27 Feb – A first-year male preening below Benjamin's Chair (Dean Jones).

Singing male

9 Apr – A male was singing from the roof of Paradise Row (Dean Jones). No instances of singing males are reported in The Birds of Lundy and this is the first record for the island that we can recall.

Late-spring/Early-summer record

27 May – One at The Battery (Rebecca & Rich Taylor).

Winter records

2 Feb – One at Benjamin's Chair (Tim Jones).

Winter records

10 Jan – One on the camping field gate (Dean Jones).

1 Dec – One; possibly a late autumn migrant as there were no later sightings in Dec.

Winter records

9 & 10 Jan – A male at Benjamin's Chair and nearby area of Tent Field (Dean Jones).

21 Jan – A female at Benjamin's Chair (Dean Jones).

8 Feb – A male at Benjamin's Chair was thought to be the same individual as seen on 9 & 10 Jan (Dean Jones).

13 Dec  – A female-type on scree above the Landing Bay (Martin Thorne).

Earliest and latest since 2006 (last year covered in full by The Birds of Lundy): Earliest 2 Apr 2011 (one found dead); Latest 29 Oct 2015 (one).

New record set for spring-passage maximum

2 & 3 May – Maxima of 20 on both dates were the highest ever recorded during spring passage through Lundy (the previous maximum being 15 on 2 May 2004). Late Apr and early May 2012 saw some extremely unsettled weather and it is likely that birds took advantage of a break in the conditions to move en masse and/or were displaced from their usual migration route.

Late date in autumn

26 Oct – A female in the vicinity of Brambles, St John’s Valley and Castle Hill was one of the latest records of recent years.

Late date in autumn

29 Oct – A single bird remains the latest since publication of The Birds of Lundy (the latest ever was on 16 Nov 2002).

Earliest and latest since 2006 (last year covered in full by The Birds of Lundy): Earliest 14 Apr 2012 (one); Latest 16 Nov 2013 (one) – the latest ever for the island, the previous latest date being 10 Nov 1952.

Notable spring-passage count

30 Apr – Four on this date remains the highest spring-passage count since publication of The Birds of Lundy; three were recorded in May 2008 and May 2017. The all-time spring maximum was 30 on 2 May 2004.

Notable autumn-passage count

2 Oct – A count of 15 (during a period of exceptionally hot weather, with warm, southerly winds) was the highest ever recorded on Lundy in Oct and remains the highest number recorded during autumn passage since publication of The Birds of Lundy (the all-time record was 25 in Sep 1958 and Sep 1972).

An early date in spring

14 Apr – One; among the earliest ever recorded on the island, although still some way behind the earliest ever, which occurred on 17 Mar in both 1955 and 1958.

Late bird in autumn

16 Nov – One; the latest ever recorded on Lundy (see above).

Notable autumn-passage count

16 Sep – A count of 11 was the second-highest total recorded during autumn passage since publication of The Birds of Lundy.

Notable spring-passage count

16 Mar – A count of 20 was, at the time, the highest spring-passage count ever recorded, but was exceeded in Mar 2018.

Breeding season summary

Seen in every month of the year, in spite of the severe weather in Feb, and although there were no reports of nesting pairs or adults feeding young, well-grown young were seen around the Terrace in the first week of Aug and seem likely to have been fledged on the island.

Notable autumn-passage count

20 Sep – A count of 18 remains the highest autumn-passage total since publication of The Birds of Lundy. The all-time autumn maximum was 70 on 10 Oct 1984.

Breeding season summary

There were many fewer records in 2010 than in other recent years and there was no indication of breeding. This is assumed to be a cumulative effect of the cold weather of Feb 2009 and Jan/Feb 2010. 

Breeding season summary

Numbers in spring were very low, following three consecutive winters with prolonged freezing conditions and there were no indications of breeding behaviour.

Breeding season summary

No evidence of breeding.

Breeding season summary

No evidence of breeding.

Breeding season summary

No evidence of breeding for the fifth consecutive year.

Breeding season summary

A pair were at Tibbetts on 6 Apr, a male was noted on 15 Apr and two birds were seen on 25 & 27 May (one on 25 May was an alarm-calling female just south of Pondsbury), but given the paucity of spring sightings it still came as a welcome surprise when, in Jun, breeding was confirmed for the first time since 2009: a pair with fledged young were on the heathland south of Pondsbury 9–15 Jun.

Breeding season sumary

There was no evidence of breeding.

Notable spring-passage count

25 Feb – A count of 14 was one of the higher spring-passage count since publication of The Birds of Lundy.

Breeding season summary

There was no evidence of breeding.

New record set for spring passage

7 Mar – A count of 24 (13 m, 11 f), all south of Halfway Wall (Dean Jones), was the highest spring-passage count since publication of The Birds of Lundy and indeed the highest spring count on record for the island (the previous record being 20 in Mar 2008).

Breeding season summary

Successful breeding was confirmed in Aug when a pair were feeding chicks just north of St Helen's Copse.

Breeding season summary

Breeding was confirmed when a pair were carrying food east of Pondsbury on 5 May and fledged young were seen in the same area on 23 May. Confirmation of a second breeding pair came on 11 May when a male was seen carrying an Emperor Moth to a nest on the seaward side of the Beach Road; both adults and three fledglings were seen there on 27 May. A third pair with two newly fledged young were on the northern slope above Pondsbury on 23 May. Finally, on 26 Jul, a fourth brood of three fledglings were with a male below the rhododendron-brash tree-planting enclosure near St Helen’s Combe.

Earliest and latest since 2006 (last year covered in full by The Birds of Lundy): Earliest 24 Feb 2019 (one); Latest 11 Nov 2011 & 2018 (one).

Ringing evidence for occurence of Greenland Wheatears

Tony Taylor has recently reviewed ringing information and comments that: "Forty of the birds ringed between 1972 and 1999 were noted as Greenland Wheatears O. o. leucorhoa and there are others that were not recorded as such but which had wing-lengths well beyond the nominate range. There has been less chance of catching Greenland Wheatears in more recent years, with little ringing activity at the best times for them and Quarter Wall Trap out of action.” (received from Tony Taylor 31 October 2007).

Greenland Wheatear ringed

2 May – An immature male Greenland Wheatear O. o. leucorhoa was trapped and ringed.

Notable spring-passage count

27 Apr – A total of 200 was among the higher counts recorded during spring passage (the record being 300 on 2 May 2004).

Good breeding season

2010 appears to have been a bumper breeding season for Wheatears on Lundy. A survey of breeding landbirds during the first week of Jun resulted in an estimated 30-40 territories, located mainly along the South End and West Side. At least 24 recently fledged juveniles – most in loose family groups and still being fed by adults – were counted. Other adults were continuing to carry food to nest sites.

Notable spring-passage count

20 Apr – A count of 200 matched the high number recorded during late April 2010.

Greenland Wheatear ringed

26 Apr – A Greenland Wheatear O. o. leucorhoa was trapped and ringed.

New record set for the highest ever count during autumn passage

1 Oct – A fall of at least 400, during a period of unseasonably hot weather, with very warm southerly winds, was (at the time) by the far the highest count ever recorded on the island during either spring or autumn migrations, the previous autumn maximum being 300 on 15 Sep 1974. A higher count was made during spring passage in May 2012, but this remains the all-time record for autumn.

Late birds in autumn

There were unusually late (though not record-breaking) stragglers into Nov, with single birds on 4th, 6th and 11th.

New record set for the highest ever count during spring passage

27 Apr to 5 May – Significant falls brought 400 on 27th, 200 on 30th, 500 on 1 May and 150 on 2 & 5 May. The estimates made for both 27 Apr and 1 May established new records for the highest numbers ever recorded in spring (eclipsing the previous record of 300 on 2 May 2004).

Greenland Wheatears 

Greenland Wheatears O. o. leucorhoa were trapped and ringed on 28 Apr (one), and 30 Apr (three). Of 100 counted around Castle Hill on 1 May, nearly all appeared to be Greenland Wheatears, typical of this relatively late phase of spring migration, and most had moved on by the next day. Though numbers of Wheatears logged did not exceed 30 after the first week of May, continued passage through the island was demonstrated by the trapping and ringing of six more Greenland birds on 23rd & 24th. Tony Taylor commented: “These six birds were notable because their mean weight was 41.5g (range: 35.8-46.6g). This contrasts with the 29 other Wheatears (probably Lundy breeding birds) ringed in the same week, which had a mean weight of 25.1g (range: 22.4-29.0g). The Greenland birds were not only larger but were carrying much more fat than the local birds, and so were probably about to start a long flight north. They were all one-year-old birds, and would probably arrive on their breeding grounds later than more experienced adults.”

Breeding season

20 Jun – 42 adults and 50 juveniles were recorded during a perimeter walk of the island.

Colour-ringing project and breeding population estimate

As a result of a colour-ringing study being led by Tony Taylor & Richard Taylor, the island’s breeding population in 2013 was estimated at about 80 pairs – the highest ever recorded and likely to be attributable, at least in part, to the eradication of rats.

Colour-ringing project and breeding population estimate

Further research based on colour-ringing resulted in a breeding population estimate of 115 pairs; another new record. Full details can be found in a paper by Tony Taylor published in the 2014 Lundy Field Society Annual Report.

Photo: Male Wheatear, Quarter Wall, 25 Apr 2014 © Richard Campey

Birds singing in total darkness

29 May – Birds were singing in total darkness below Tibbetts at around 02.00 hrs and near Pondsbury at about 04.00 hrs (Richard & Rebecca Taylor).

Colour-ringing project and breeding population estimate

Tony Taylor and Richard Taylor continued their colour-ringing study, marking 48 new birds and logging sightings of 29 birds ringed in previous years. The survival rate from 2015 to 2016 among the colour-ringed birds was 44%. The all-island breeding population in 2016 was estimated at 110 pairs.

Greenland Wheatears

A female Greenland Wheatear O. o. leucorhoa on the west end of the Airfield on 5 Jun was caught and ringed (Richard & Rebecca Taylor). On 8 Sep, an adult female Greenland bird was caught by hand at 23:00hrs in the Old Light Manx Sheawater colony. Perhaps newly arrived, its weight was quite low, but after being kept overnight and ringed, it flew off strongly the following morning (Richard Taylor, Rosie Hall). The last bird of the year, on 27 Oct, was considered to be a first-winter male Greenland Wheatear (Chris Baillie).

Colour-ringing project and breeding population estimate

The colour-ringing project under the BTO Retrapping Adults for Survival scheme entered its fifth year. A further 51 birds were newly colour-ringed, whilst 48 birds marked in previous years (2013–2016) were resighted. One of the latter, ringed in 2015, was seen on Guernsey on 13 Mar (2017), then back on Lundy 11 days later. The breeding population within the main study area, from the Castle, along the south and west coast as far as Halfway Wall, was estimated at 53 pairs and for the island as a whole, 121 pairs – yet another new record for the island.

Colour-ringing project and breeding population estimate

The ongoing colour-ringing study of the island’s breeding population showed that at least 56% of the birds breeding in 2017 survived migration to and from their African winter quarters and bred on Lundy in 2018. The main study area (from the Castle, along the South End and West Side as far north as Halfway Wall) was estimated to have held 53 pairs in 2018, the same as in 2017, but the whole-island population estimate was down slightly at 114 pairs.

Late date in autumn

11 Nov – A single bird, in Lighthouse Field, equalled the latest date in autumn since publication of The Birds of Lundy (see also Nov 2011).

Exceptionally early arrival in spring

Dean Jones’s sighting of a male at Jenny’s Cove during the morning of 24 Feb was (by seven days) the earliest Lundy record for this species and one of the first seen in the whole of the UK in 2019.

Colour-ringing project and breeding population estimate

Summarising the continuing long-term BTO Retrapping Adults for Survival (RAS) colour-ringing study of Lundy’s Wheatears, Tony Taylor reports that 53% of the breeding birds recorded in 2018 survived their migration and returned to breed in 2019. This was slightly below the 2013-18 average return rate. Even so, there were a record 54 pairs in the study area (the south and west coasts between the Castle and Halfway Wall), and the population estimate for the whole island was 118 pairs. This is the second highest total recorded, after 121 in 2017. A colour-ringed male, holding territory on the sidelands just south of Quarter Wall Copse, was originally ringed on Lundy in 2012 (with colour-rings added in 2015).

Ringing

Colour-ring sighting: A Wheatear ringed and colour-ringed as a breeding adult male on Lundy on 3 Jun 2015 (ring no. Z660128; colour-ring combination: left leg, pale blue over black; right leg, metal over stripe) was seen at Pulias, Guernsey, Channel Islands on 13 Mar 2017 (649 days; 244 km; SE 142°) then re-sighted on Lundy from 24 Mar to 4 Jun 2017. This is the first – and to date only – sighting of a Lundy colour-ringed Wheatear away from the island, from among the >200 individuals marked to the end of 2017.

First for Lundy

18 Oct – One was seen briefly between the Beach Road and the 'Goat Path' (Martin Elcoate). Seen in rapidly deteriorating weather conditions, the bird could not be relocated. Fortunately, some snatched photos, followed by Martin’s doggedly patient and forensic marshalling of all the evidence, ultimately led to the clinching of a superb first for the island. Record accepted by BBRC.

First for Lundy

9 Jun – A juvenile was seen perched and in flight in Millcombe walled gardens on 9 Jun (Tim Davis, Tim Jones, Martin Palmer). This is the first substantiated record for Lundy and perhaps one of the most unexpected sightings on the island of recent decades!

New record

30 Sep – One was seen briefly in lower Millcombe (Steve Howells & Tim Pett). After a long wait for the first, the island's second Dipper followed in relatively short order.

Breeding season summary

There were about 120 adults in Jun and 150 chicks fledged during the breeding season.

Breeding season summary

The first chicks of the year fledged from a nestbox in the lambing shed on 16 May; to have four chicks surviving to fledging this early in the season was an unusual occurrence. The adult population was estimated to be between 80 and 100 individuals at most, with definite records of at least 44 different individuals (Ian Cleasby). A female was still feeding fledglings on 5 Sep.

Breeding season summary

The breeding season was remarkably early, with the first chicks fledging on 1 May, indicating that egg-laying must have commenced around the beginning of Apr. During the previous two breeding seasons no eggs had even hatched until the start of May. A large number of first-year birds were present in the spring, suggesting high recruitment in 2008 (Ian Cleasby).

Breeding season summary

The 2011 breeding season was very successful, with 151 clutches laid, beginning on 3 Apr, and 475 nestlings hatched. The post-breeding population was composed of at least 230 individually marked birds, including 102 adults and 128 successfully fledged young. Sparrowhawks routinely entered the lambing shed to hunt during the autumn and winter, leading to a significant drop in sparrow numbers. While 123 marked individuals (of all ages) were recorded in Nov, only 41 were caught in Feb 2012 (Isabel Winney & Yu-Hsun Hsu).

Breeding season summary

See comment above concerning the impacts of winter 2011/2012 Sparrowhawk predation.

The 2012 breeding season started late, with the first egg laid on the latest date since comprehensive monitoring began in 2000. This led to a delay in the first fledglings, with none before June, in contrast with past breeding seasons. The mean number of chicks ringed annually from 2000 to 2011 was 179 (range 68 – 335). In 2012, the University of Sheffield team ringed 200 chicks. So, despite the late start to the season, 2012 was more productive than the average year, but was not exceptional (Isabel Winney).

Breeding season summary

On 8 Aug the post-breeding population was estimated at 230 individuals, composed of 130 breeding adults and 100 young of the year (Isabel Winney). On 13 Nov the research team estimated the population to be about 200 individuals.

Breeding season summary

The 2014 breeding season started very early, with the first egg laid on 15 Mar – the earliest date since comprehensive monitoring began in 2000 (though monitoring in previous years generally did not begin as early as it did in 2014, which probably reduced the likelihood of recording any very early clutches). 2014 was also a record year in terms of fledglings ringed (553) and almost a record year in terms of number of broods recorded (241, the record being 248). A few birds bred up to four times, something very unusual in the Lundy population. By the end of Jul, only a handful of birds were risking new breeding attempts and by 19 Aug (the date that the sparrow research team left the island), only two pairs were still feeding chicks. Many of the 2014 fledglings as well as many of the adults were caught in two subsequent winter trips. In Dec 2014, 100 individuals were caught, followed by 85 in Feb 2015.

The highest field count of the year was 160 on 26 Aug, immediately after the breeding season. As in some previous years, a small number of individuals appeared to have learnt how to make a living from picking about under the tables inside the Tavern; three birds were watched doing this on 27 Oct.

Breeding season summary

The 2015 breeding season was average in terms of starting time and number of fledglings ringed. The first egg was laid on 11 April. Surprisingly, the totals for pairs, broods and fledglings were reduced by 50%, 50% and 60% respectively, when compared to the breeding season of 2014. However, it’s important to keep in mind that the breeding season of 2014 involved the biggest population ever recorded. During 2015 the sparrow research team recorded a total of 122 broods and ringed 227 fledglings from April to August. The main reason for the reduction in the number of breeding pairs in the summer of 2015 might have been the continuous presence of Sparrowhawks and Merlins during the previous winter.

Breeding season summary

After a winter visit in February, when 71 individuals were caught, researchers expected the population to be lower in summer 2016, compared to 2015. However, with slightly higher numbers for both broods and fledglings, the summer of 2016 showed that accurate population predictions for Lundy House Sparrows are difficult to make. The breeding season started with the first egg being laid on 14 April, and ended relatively late with the first egg of the last brood being laid on 11 August. With 22 more broods than 2015, and 146 broods in total, producing 253 fledglings, the summer of 2016 can be classified as an average year. A ringing trip in November 2016 showed high numbers of sparrows. A total of 105 individuals were caught, compared to the 71 in February.

Breeding season summary

The 2017 breeding season started extremely early; by the time of the team’s arrival on Lundy on 22 April, many nests already contained chicks of at least a few days old. The first egg was estimated to have been laid around 31 March. What sparked this early onset of the breeding season is only speculative, but could have been the relatively mild winter, followed by some early warmth in spring. Unfortunately, most of these early broods did not make it; a lot of chicks died during a cold spell that lasted for a few days. Most birds waited for a week or so before they started laying again and this time the chicks fared much better than the first wave. At the end of the season researchers had accounted for 218 broods – a much higher total than in 2016 – and 317 chicks had been ringed. The Lambing Shed was back in business in 2017, hosting many broods. Given that the area remained undisturbed during winter 2016/2017, sparrows had time to prospect and claim nestboxes, which they took full advantage of. In November, the team returned to Lundy for about a week to catch surviving fledglings and adults, trapping a total of 144 individuals, so numbers remained high after a successful breeding season.

Breeding season summary

The breeding season began quite late in comparison to previous years and though sparrows can have up to four broods a year, few had more than two. There were also few adults from the previous year’s fledglings, suggesting that the young birds didn’t fare very well in the cold. Those breeding in the lambing shed appeared to do a bit better, as birds there began breeding before elsewhere on the island (likely due to the shelter provided). Overall however, the breeding season was largely successful. In total, there were 175 broods, a fairly average number compared to other years, but lower than in 2017 when 218 broods were recorded. Interestingly, the number of chicks didn’t vary much between years. In 2018, 309 chicks were ringed (chicks are ringed when 12 days old and fledge when roughly 17 days old), whereas 317 chicks were ringed in 2017. This could be due to parents raising larger broods in 2018 or a higher mortality rate of young chicks (fewer reaching the age of 12 days) in 2017.

Breeding season summary

The 2019 season started very late, with only eight broods in the entirety of May, just one of which contained chicks that survived to fledging. Mainland birds were easily on their second or even third brood by the start of June, whereas the Lundy breeding season had really only just begun to take off. We speculate this was because of cold night-time temperatures throughout May. The spell of warm weather in February 2019 caused many other species to begin breeding very early in the year. However, unlike many other passerines, House Sparrows are not reliant on particular seasonal events (such as tree masting) and therefore can afford to
wait until conditions become more suitable. The late season effectively meant that the Lundy sparrows skipped a brood. Typically, the island birds have three broods, with some higher-quality pairs rearing four, but most birds in 2019 had two broods, with only a handful having three. There was a total of 103 broods, compared to 175 in 2018. Ringing occurs when the chicks are 12 days old, with almost all birds reaching this age going on to fledge successfully. Some 217 nestlings were ringed in 2019, compared with 309 nestlings ringed in 2018, so productivity was much lower in 2019. However, the smaller number of fledged birds is not concerning, being due simply to the delayed start to nesting.

Ringing

Colour-ringing movement

One of the Lundy House Sparrows colour-ringed as a nestling by the University of Sheffield on 3 May 2011 was seen in Hartland, North Devon mainland, on 27 February 2012. It was thought to have been in the Hartland area for about two weeks before the sighting was confirmed by Lundy sparrow researcher Isabel Winney. This is the first proven movement of House Sparrows between Lundy and the mainland (or vice versa).

New record

22 Aug to 2 Sep – A remarkable influx occurred at the end of Aug, when three were seen near the helipad on 22nd, rising to 12 on 24th, with 11 remaining to 29th and the last nine remaining until 2 Sep, when seen just south of Old Light (Richard Taylor, Tony Taylor et al.). The mobile flock tended to frequent the main tracks between the Village and Old Light, and between the Village and Quarter Wall. The most recent previous Tree Sparrow record for the island was of a single bird on 29 Jul 2000 (though there was also an unconfirmed report of one in early Aug 2008), but it’s necessary to go as far back as 1975 to find a count of more than 12 (namely 16 on 29 May that year). Given that there are no Tree Sparrows breeding on nearby parts of the mainland, the birds’ likely origin was a matter of debate. On one hand, their appearance coincided with a period of blustery NW winds, so perhaps they had come from the thriving breeding population in Ireland? On the other hand, significant Tree Sparrow movements were reported along the East coast of England in late Aug and early Sep (e.g. 300 at Spurn on 31 Aug, 26 on the Farne Islands on 2 Sep), perhaps suggesting a northern British, or even continental origin. Elsewhere, targeted conservation efforts in parts of southern England have resulted in locally high breeding productivity from nestbox schemes. Whatever the answer, the Lundy Tree Sparrows were a welcome late-summer surprise for those who saw them. Record accepted by Devon Bird Recorder.

 Photo © Tim Davis

New record

29 & 30 May – One was feeding outside Brambles (Ann & Tony Taylor). Record accepted by Devon Bird Recorder.

Summary

In spite of the extremely low numbers recorded during the first few months of the year (ones and twos only), breeding was proven when an adult carrying food was seen in lower Millcombe on 3 May (R. Campey). As usual, numbers reached a peak – albeit a modest one – in Oct, with seven on 3rd. Although the clearance of rhododendron has reduced the extent of suitable nesting habitat, the ‘dead hedges’ of rhodie brashings and developing scrub between St Helen’s Copse and the Terrace continue to provide opportunities for this species outside of Millcombe.

Summary

During the period 29 May to 2 Jun, a pair carrying food was seen below the Beach Road south of the small Turkey Oak clump, an adult was seen in Millcombe and another along the Lower East Side Path. The island’s breeding population was estimated as one to three pairs (Tim Davis & Tim Jones). Once again, the peak count of the year – seven – was recorded in Oct, perhaps reflecting increased observer coverage in that month, but maybe also a degree of movement through the island. Given that the island population is now very small, the ringing records during the year (data supplied by Tony Taylor) are of particular interest: an adult male retrapped in spring had originally been ringed on Lundy as a first-year bird in Sep 2009. Two other adults, caught in early autumn, were undergoing their annual full moult and were therefore likely to be resident birds. Four first-year birds were ringed in Sep.

Summary

The island’s small breeding population seems to be holding its own, with a max spring total of seven singing males (Millcombe and the Lower East Side Path as far north as the Terrace). The highest counts of the year were nine on 22 Oct and ten on 26 Nov.

Summary

Three singing males were present in early Jun, but there was no earlier spring survey and no confirmation of successful breeding. The highest count was six on 24 & 25 Oct. Seven different individuals were handled by ringers in 2014; three adults (two retraps from previous years) and four birds of the year.

Summary

The highest count in spring was six on 15 Apr. During the period May–Jul, song was heard in Millcombe and St John’s Valley (two singing against each other on 28 May), from below the Terrace and at St Helen’s Copse. However there was no confirmation of breeding, or even evidence of nesting. Although first-year birds were trapped in the autumn, these could have dispersed or migrated from the mainland; a possibility underlined by the apparent influx of birds in Oct, when nine were logged on 14th, and seven on 15th & 28th. Thorough coverage of suitable habitat during Sep had yielded only single birds on just four dates.

Summary

No counts reached double digits. The spring max was four on 6 Mar and 4 Apr. During late May and the first half of Jun, single birds were recorded in Millcombe and on the Terrace. Breeding was confirmed with a record of a recently fledged juvenile in late Jul. Autumn counts peaked at five on 13 Sep and seven on 20 Nov. Nine indivduals were handled by ringers during the year.

Summary – notable counts in both spring and autumn

There were signs of birds passing through the island in late Mar, with counts of eight on 22nd and 11 on 27th – the latter the highest count for Lundy since 2005. This total was exceeded in the autumn when there were 13 on 9 Oct (the highest since Oct 2004), and eight or nine on six other dates during Oct, suggestive of both a good breeding season and some passage movement. Successful breeding confirmed: song was heard in lower Millcombe on 30 Apr and a pair were feeding fledged young by the gas store in on 21 May, when there were two males singing in Millcombe (Tim Davis & Tim Jones). A territory-holding singing male was heard between the Terrace and Quarry Beach on 30 Apr and in the same area in late May, and one was singing above White Beach on 22 May.

Summary

One was carrying nesting material in Smelly Gully (lower Millcombe) on 4 May and an adult was taking food to chicks in upper Millcombe on 2 & 31 May. On 2 Jun there was a singing male near Brambles stream, a pair carrying food just below Smelly Gully dam and an adult feeding fledged young by Millcombe gates. Further singing males were noted just north of St Helen’s Copse and just south of Quarter Wall Copse on 3 Jun. Altogether, there were three nests in Millcombe, one below the Terrace and a possible nest along the Lower East Side Path above White Beach (Dean Jones). There were hints of a small post-breeding or autumn passage influx, with counts reaching 11 on 24 Sep and 19 Oct.

Summary

An encouraging year, with good overwinter survival apparent and double-digit counts in seven months, peaking at 16 on both 19 Oct and 25 Dec. Breeding confirmed: at least four pairs in Millcombe, one at St Helen’s Combe, one above White Beach, one near South Light, one below the Terrace and another at Quarter Wall Copse. Adults were feeding chicks at nests in Millcombe on 2 & 27 May, and fledglings were seen on 7 Jun.

Ringing

Ringing control: The previously suspected occurrence of at least some autumn passage of Dunnocks through Lundy was confirmed when a first-year bird ringed on Lundy on 14 October 2010 (ring no.L037967) was recaptured on the Wirral Peninsula, Merseyside on 08 April 2011 (176 days; 267 km; NNE 23°). The BTO Migration Atlas shows that British-bred Dunnocks are extremely sedentary – more than 95% staying within 1 km of their place of hatching. Continental Dunnocks are, however, highly migratory and this recovery raises the intriguing thought of a bird moving north west from Central Europe, to winter in the British Isles, in the manner of many Central European Blackcaps.

Earliest and latest since 2006 (last year covered in full by The Birds of Lundy): Earliest in spring 22 Mar 2007 (one; the earliest ever recorded on the island), Latest in spring 13 Jun 2010 (one); Earliest in autumn 23 Aug 2011 (one); Latest in autumn 17 Oct 2009 (one).

Blue-headed Wagtail

27 Apr – A male of the nominate race, 'Blue-headed Wagtail' M. f. flava, was seen in St Helen's Field during the annual day-trip by members of Devon Birds (R. Doble et al.). Details accepted by Devon Bird Recorder.

Intermediate-race bird

10 to 12 Jun – A singing male, showing characteristics intermediate between Blue-headed Wagtail M. f. flava and Yellow Wagtail M. f. flavissima was seen around the Village, mainly in St Helen’s Field.

Notable autumn-passage count

8 Sep – Five; remains the joint highest autumn-passage count since publication of The Birds of Lundy (see also Oct 2011).

Notable autumn-passage count

2 Oct– Five; remains the joint highest spring-passage count since publication of The Birds of Lundy (see also Sep 2010).

Possible eastern-race bird

7 Oct – The call of a single bird in flight was considered to be typical of one of the eastern races, rather than Yellow (M. f. flavissima) or Blue-headed Wagtail (M. f. flava) (Ivan Lakin & Kevin Rylands).

Blue-headed Wagtail

19 & 21 May – One of two birds seen on both dates (in South West Field on 21st) showed characteristics of the nominate race Blue-headed Wagtail M. f. flava (Mark Dyer).

Grey-headed Wagtail

31 May – A male in St Helen's Field showed characteristics of the race 'Grey-headed Wagtail'  M. f. thunbergi  (Chris Townend, Pete Clabburn, Philip Lymbery). Record accepted by DBRC; the fifth Lundy occurrence of Grey-headed Wagtail, the last being in Jun 1997.

Grey-headed Wagtail

14 & 15 Sep – An adult male feeding around sheep in the Lighthouse Field showed the characteristics of Grey-headed Wagtail M. f. thunbergi, which breeds in Scandinavia and western Russia (Tim Davis & Tim Jones). Record accepted by DBRC; the sixth for Lundy.

Notable spring-passage count

5 May – Seven (including two Blue-headed Wagtails) remains the highest spring-passage count since publication of The Birds of Lundy.

Blue-headed Wagtails

5 & 6 May – Two female Blue-headed Wagtails M. f. flava, keeping company with Yellow Wagtails and feeding around the ponies, were in Barton, St Helen’s and Tillage Fields (Tim Davis, Tim Jones, Joanne Wilby et al.). Record accepted by Devon Bird Recorder.

Blue-headed Wagtails

24 to 26 Apr – A male in Barton Field.

15 to 22 May – A male in Barton Field on 15^th & 16^th and again on 21^st and 22^nd – it is unclear if one or two individuals were involved.

Records accepted by Devon Bird Recorder.

Grey-headed Wagtail – records subject to acceptance by DBRC

26 May – A male in St Helen's Field showed characteristics of the race 'Grey-headed Wagtail' M. f. thunbergi (Richard Campey, Luke Marriner et al.).

15 Sep – An individual in St Helen's Field showed characteristics of the race 'Grey-headed Wagtail' M. f. thunbergi (Shaun Robson et al.).

Notable autumn-passage count

14 Sep – A count of 11 remains the highest since publication of The Birds of Lundy.

Notable autumn-passage count

15 Oct – Six; among the higher counts of recent years.

Effect of cold winters

Three consecutive cold winters appear to have had a significant adverse effect on this species, with one on 9 Mar being the only record during the first eight months of the year. Even in autumn, the only reported occurrences were singles on seven dates between 29 Sep and 23 Oct and two on 2 Oct – the poorest showing for many years.

Unusual date in late spring/early summer

7 Jun – The only spring record was of one in the ditch near the cattle grid outside Square Cottage; an unusual date for Lundy.

Notable autumn-passage count

17 Sep & 2 Oct – Five on both dates were among the higher counts of recent years.

Unusual dates in late spring/early summer

14 May to 27 Jun – There was an unusual series of records of single birds on seven dates during this period; perhaps a single, long-staying individual?

Late-winter/early-spring record

17 Feb – One flew over South West Point.

Unusual dates in late spring/early summer

16 May to 26 Jun – For the third year running there were unusually late spring/early summer records involving single birds on 16 May and 2, 3 & 26 Jun.

Unusual dates in late spring/early summer

5 & 6 Jun – Two reported on both dates.

Breeding summary

Successful breeding has been confirmed in nearly every year since 2006 (the last year covered in full by The Birds of Lundy), through the observation of adults carrying food and/or feeding fledglings, but it has proved difficult to pin down the number of territories and broods in most seasons.

Breeding season

Early Jun – Up to six territories were identified during a survey of breeding landbirds in early Jun, though it is unknown how many pairs bred successfully.

Notable spring-passage count of White Wagtails

20 Apr – Twelve White Wagtails remains the highest spring-passage count since publication of The Birds of Lundy. 

Notable spring-passage count of White Wagtails

14 Apr – Twelve White Wagtails equalled the highest count since publication of The Birds of Lundy.

Exceptional autumn-passage count of White Wagtails

16 Sep – An early-morning fall of White Wagtails numbered at least 100, concentrated mainly at the southern ends of the Tent Field and South West Field. Most had left the island by 10.00 hrs (Tim Davis & Tim Jones). This was one of the higher counts of White or Pied Wagtails ever recorded on the island and remains by far the highest count since publication of The Birds of Lundy.

Breeding season

Three pairs bred successfully.

Notable spring-passage count of Pied Wagtails

8 Apr – A count of 20 is the highest spring-passage total for 'Pied Wagtail' since publication of The Birds of Lundy (though it is not known what proportion were definitively assigned to race).

Breeding season

5 Jul – Two recently fledged young were in Millcombe (Mike Archer).

2018

Breeding season

A pair of Pied Wagtails were carrying food to a nest near the stonecrusher on 5 Jun, whilst a second pair, also carrying food, were perched on Quarry Cottages and active around Brick Field on 6 Jun (Tim Davis & Tim Jones). A third pair bred successfully in Millcombe walled gardens (Dean Jones).

Breeding season

A pair of Pied Wagtails were gathering food for chicks in the farmyard on 3 Jul, while a second pair were feeding two young in Millcombe on 26 Jul.

Ringing

Ringing recovery (on-island): A Pied Wagtail ringed as an adult female on Lundy on 24 Apr 2005 was found freshly dead on Lundy on 27 Jul 2009 – some 1,555 days later.